PrintEmail
Comment
Ergonomic Keyboards that Aim for Less Pain
Posted by Paul Freibott on July 21, 2006 - 7:58am.
keyboardsreal

Last month, LIME looked at the benefits of several ergonomic computer mice and similar devices. Today, we look at their constant companions—keyboards—which despite being attached to some rather speedy late-model technology, remain as antiquated as a Model T.

Few realize that today’s keyboards date to the 1860s and the first modern typewriter. They haven’t changed much since, and what’s more, the QWERTY layout (named for the top row of keys) was inefficient by design right from the start, with common letters moved to the fringes to keep fast-fingered typists from jamming their machines. As many know all too well, the keyboard’s unforgiving straight-lined design requires awkward hand placement. For some, this means pain in the wrists, hands, arms, and upper body.

Frequent keyboard use can lead to Repetitive Strain Injury, a condition that affects the nerves and soft tissue such as muscles and tendons. At its worst, RSI can cause chronic aches, decreased range of motion, and permanent nerve damage.

A few tech revolutions later, it’s amazing to think we haven’t done better than early typewriter design. Or have we? If you have pain or numbness when you type (or worse—even after you stop), consider investing in an ergonomic keyboard. Alone, it won’t cure your pain or inflammation, but it might help prevent a future flare-up after you’ve gotten the medical help you need.

Each of the three keyboards I tested takes a unique ergonomic approach: curved and wireless; split and elevated; and bowl-shaped (as well as split). Because each person’s body is different, you’ll want to see which feels best to you.

 

Microsoft Wireless Laser Desktop 6000

Looking and sounding a bit like a dashboard on the Starship Enterprise, the Microsoft Wireless Laser Desktop 6000 pairs a curvy keyboard with a molded mouse, both of which are wireless. The "Comfort Curve" keyboard recalls the original Microsoft Natural Keyboard, except that it’s flat, not rounded and raised, and it’s not technically split. Instead, the key rows form a gentle smile. Some users may find the flatness uncomfortable because your forearms still pronate, but the untethered aspect allows you to more easily place things wherever they feel most comfy, even if that means pulling it into your lap every now and then like a notebook. (Doing this allowed me to fully relax my arms and shoulders every so often.) A thin cushion wraps around the keys, giving the heels of your hands a place to relax. The function keys default to useful actions like Save, Open, Close, New document/window, Spell check, Undo, and Print, while separate hot keys open My Documents, Web/Home, Calculator, and your five favorite websites. Addressing eye strain, a unique slide zoom makes letters larger with just a touch. The mouse, while ostensibly ergonomic, was still too small for my long fingers and didn’t feel quite as nice as other mice I’ve tried. However, its scroll wheel was exceptionally smooth. Because both components are wireless, you need to install software, insert batteries (for the planet, go rechargeable), and plug in a receiver before tapping away.

Compatible with: PS/2 or USB port, PC or Mac

Who should use it: Fans of quick-acting hot keys and fidgety users who like to type in their laps

Cost: $73.95

Where to Buy: Amazon

 

Key Ovation Goldtouch Adjustable Keyboard

The Goldtouch keyboard from Key Ovation shape-shifts to suit individual users in two ways. It’s split down the middle and hinged, so that the two halves can open wide to the sides, plus it folds into a tent shape up to four inches high. Once you find the perfect positioning, you lock it in place with a lever. After testing high and low and splits of various degrees on a Mac-compatible version, I found that the most pleasing configuration was fully folded (i.e. with the tent peak at its highest) and with the keys separated about an inch. This way, my palms nearly faced each other. In contrast, all flat configurations felt unhealthy and unnatural—the folding seems essential to prevent unnecessary painful twisting. The Goldtouch boasts no extra hot keys, other than a forward delete button (something I’ve always liked on PCs and missed on Macs). My arms were basically unsupported, but by keeping my elbows at my sides, bending my arms at 90 degrees, and sitting close to my desk, I felt relaxed and actually sat up straighter. Make sure your chair is high enough so your forearms are no higher than your elbows—something you should do no matter what keyboard you choose.

Compatible with: PC or Mac

Who should use it: Wrist pain sufferers or anyone who wants a finely-tuned, personalized setup

Cost: $129.95 for both Mac & PC
Where to Buy: Amazon PC Mac

 

Kinesis Contoured Keyboard

Of the three models tested, the Kinesis Contoured Keyboard was the most unusual. It took the longest time to adapt—several days, something Kinesis (which also makes an adjustable split keyboard similar to Key Ovation’s) warns about in advance. But if you have the time to learn, the investment might be worth it. This keyboard was developed in the early 90s, and has two unique bowl shapes holding the keys. Hands are separated by nearly six inches. On each concave side, the keys are lined up directly atop one another in columns, not staggered, and set at different depths to match finger lengths. (The D key, for example, is deepest-set to accommodate the longer middle finger.) Several important keys—Enter, Space, Backspace, Control, and Alt—are in the center and operated exclusively by the thumbs, so short-thumbed folks should think twice. A nice wide area gives the hands a place to rest while the fingers do all the work. Although typing goes more slowly at first and probably takes weeks to master, this seems to be a comfortable way to work while avoiding bending the wrists. My two peeves: audible digitized clicks and beeps when you type, and arrow keys directly under the bottom row of letters, making them easy to hit by mistake. Typos are unavoidable at first, but in two days, my typing speed and accuracy improved. If you have that time and maybe even a little more, the higher-end "Advantage" model comes equipped with the rare, alternative Dvorak keyboard layout, a simpler, healthier, newer alternative to the 19th-century QWERTY that, unfortunately for our fingers, never caught on.

Compatible with: PC (PS/2 or USB port) or Mac (USB only)

Who should use it: Patient keyboarders with ample free time—or sufficiently painful symptoms—to merit considerable retraining.

Cost: $209.99 for "Essential" model (PS/2 port, PC only) $254.99 for "Classic" model (PS/2 port, PC only, programmable) $264.99 for "Advantage" model (USB port, PC or Mac) $314.99 for "Advantage Pro" model (USB port, PC or Mac, programmable)

Where to Buy: Amazon Essential Classic Advantage Advantage Pro

Photo: Key Ovation



Related Shop Items


<em>Anonymous</em>'s picture
I find these
by Anonymous on July 21, 2006 - 8:28am
Impossible to use
<em>Paul_Freibott</em>'s picture
I'll never go back
by Paul_Freibott on July 21, 2006 - 12:20pm

Gee, I hope the standard keyboard works OK for you then.  I hate to see people in pain.  Personally, I'm addicted to curvy keyboards!  But like I said, we're all different.


<em>TheU</em>'s picture
i dont really mind the
by TheU on July 21, 2006 - 10:48am
i dont really mind the straight layout of keyboards, as opposed to the ones that are curved to be easier on the wrists and hands. id say i spend a lot of time at a computer and the most of the pain is only in my neck.
<em>Paul_Freibott</em>'s picture
neck
by Paul_Freibott on July 21, 2006 - 11:59am

Over the years, I've become somewhat of a folk expert on ergonomic computer use.  So, with all appropriate caveats about me not being qualified to dispense medical advice...here's what's worked for me.  For neck problems, I would suggest two things: 1) elevate your monitor so when you're sitting up straight, you're looking directly at it at eye level.  For me, that meant putting it on top of four phone books.  2) neck problems are often related to stress, physical and mental.  Try taking a vacation, exercising, meditating, or at least taking a hot bath, followed by ice.  Taking an anti-inflammatory might also help in the short term.

 

Lastly, I too get neck pain, but that's usually after it's worked its way up from my wrists and past the shoulders.  Yikes!  That's when I stop typing for a while.  I don't need it to go into my brain.  :)


<em>TheU</em>'s picture
those are good tips, thanks
by TheU on July 21, 2006 - 3:13pm
those are good tips, thanks a lot
<em>dreamymo</em>'s picture
neck pain
by dreamymo on July 24, 2006 - 6:14pm

ive been dealing with neck pain for years and the only thing that helped me has been my pilates sessions -- for me i keep my shoulders shrugged and that is causing neck tension. however with pilates, all that is gone now that i am building up muscle strength in my shoulders and back


<em>Chris</em>'s picture
I also
by Chris on July 21, 2006 - 12:28pm
Prefer the straight keyboards, maybe it's because I've used them for so long, and I never really have any discomfort. I am sure after a few more years of pecking away, my fingers will love me for switching to something more ergonomic.
<em>Anonymous</em>'s picture
got bendable?
by Anonymous on July 21, 2006 - 12:48pm
I used to work for a company that had rubber roll up type keyboards. They were flexible and caused less stress to the tips of your fingertips as you typed. They had more "give" to them. That's the best way to describe them. I haven't been able to find them anywhere. Does anyone know where they can be located?
<em>Anonymous</em>'s picture
got bendable post 2
by Anonymous on July 21, 2006 - 1:30pm
<em>Anonymous</em>'s picture
Kinesis Contoured Keyboard is great but expensive
by Anonymous on July 27, 2006 - 12:16am
I was a professional computer programmer and I have carpal tunnel syndrome, severe enough that a hand specialist orthopedic surgeon wanted to do surgery. I didn't do surgery, I had acupuncture instead. The acupuncture worked great at relieving my pain. But to prevent further flare-ups I also got the Wall St. brokerage that I worked for to buy me one of these keyboards and an ergonomic mouse. It took a week or two to get used to, but they are great!!!! Most of my fellow programmers got them too after they tried mine. I higly recommend them for any serious computer user. They are pricey, but how much is you health worth to you. I was fortunate to be able to expense them. At home, I have a cordless keyboard and mouse - more reasonably priced - and good enough for my purposes.
<em>Anonymous</em>'s picture
kinesis contoured and others
by Anonymous on July 30, 2006 - 10:53am
You said: "My two peeves: audible digitized clicks and beeps when you type..." What do you mean? Why would there be beeps? Are they frequent? Which keyboard in your opinion has the lightest, softest touch and shortest travel time of keys--Kinesis, Goldtouch, or other? If you've done a lot of research into these keyboards, have you looked at the Pace or the Comfort? If anyone has any advice or comparisons on ergonomic keyboards, please email me at randy at randypowell dot com. The frustrating thing is that there's no way to try these keyboards out before buying them. If you buy one and don't like it, you can return it but have to pay a 10 - 30 percent restocking fee. so you're paying these companies 50 bucks for the privilege of to try out their product!!!
<em>DaVinci</em>'s picture
nice keyboards
by DaVinci on August 11, 2006 - 11:59am
keyboards
<em>Anonymous</em>'s picture
sloping tray things
by Anonymous on September 7, 2006 - 12:31pm
I find my laptop keyboard good and 'givey', though it can still hurt sometimes, and it saves my wrists rather than my fingers, which are still as sore as anything.
For typing on my desktop I'm getting a tray that gives the keyboard a reverse slope after having them recommended by my doc (full story <a href="http://www.goodbyersi.com/2006/08/cool-anti-rsi-keyboard-tray.html">here</a>) - the one I tried out was really comfortable. Again, it they seem to be better at tackling wrist pain than finger pain. I hear the roll-up 'boards are very good for that, though.

User login


Join Lime Now, it's free

Meet New People

milkyway (View Profile)

Interests: Practicing DJing, Feng Shui, Spirituality, Candle and Soap making, Yoga, Camping, Bicycling, Movies, Music
Inspiration: Music. Nature.

More new members | Create your profile