PrintEmail
Comment
Fat Free Half and Half: Does it Add Up?
Posted by Kerry Trueman on June 9, 2006 - 2:02pm.
files/images/prod/618/half.gif

One New Year's resolution we could all benefit from, women especially, is to consume more calcium. Dairy products are one way to get your daily dose of this crucial bone-building mineral. What you don't need are the fat and cholesterol that full fat dairy products also contain.

I buy low fat and fat free dairy products as much as possible. Nonfat yogurt tastes fine to me. Fat free buttermilk? Wouldn't bake without it. And I couldn't make my famous cream-free ice cream without fat free sweetened condensed milk.

But fat free half and half sounds oxymoronic to me. What is half and half, if not fat? A fellow foodie told me it wasn't half bad. Give it a chance, she said.

But none of the stores I shop at even stocked it. Finally I found Land O' Lakes fat free half and half at a conventional supermarket. But I couldn't bring myself to buy it. First, it only came in a half gallon carton. What in the world would you do with that much ersatz half and half?

What bothered me more was the second ingredient, after milk: corn syrup. It's not as bad as high fructose corn syrup, but corn syrup's still not a natural food; the corn industry concocted it in the seventies as a cheap alternative to sugar.

So which is the lesser of two evils: high fat, cholesterol-laden natural cream, or agribusiness's manufactured sweetener? There's no consensus on fat free half and half in the foodie blogosphere: some people swear it makes a great creamed soup; others share my skepticism.

Has anyone tasted this stuff? If you've tried any brand of fat free half and half on the market, I'm curious to know what you thought of it. Especially those who've bought it by the half gallon. Do you bathe in it, drink it by the glass, or what?



Related Shop Items


<em>Anonymous</em>'s picture
land o lakes fat free half and half
by Anonymous on January 5, 2006 - 1:03pm

i buy this all the time. it tastes just like half and half to me. just less fat. i am trying to decrease the fat in my diet. and when i use if for my coffee, it is the best. doesn’t taste bad at all!! i use it instead of milk alot and to thicken just about anything.


<em>Anonymous</em>'s picture
fat free half and half
by Anonymous on January 5, 2006 - 5:30pm

I do not like half and half but I will use the fat free half and half when I make home made mash potatoes.


<em>kat</em>'s picture
what about Skim Plus?
by kat on January 5, 2006 - 5:30pm

I swear by an enhanced skim milk called Skim Plus, I don’t know if it’s available where you are but I use it in everything from mashed potatoes to mac’n’cheese. We even put it in our coffee and on our cereal. It’s got a rich creamy taste which comes from (I think) added nonfat milk solids. No corn syrup! It’s not organic, though. Ah, the tradeoffs we have to make…


<em>dreamymo</em>'s picture
pick your poison
by dreamymo on January 5, 2006 - 4:23pm

my roommate used to use this all the time when she was trying to get her weight down and couldnt stomach skim milk in her coffee, but i also worry about the corn syrup aspect. I am all for reduced fat and fat free items but not at the sake of overall health. Its the same as many of the traditional ‘diet’ foods that are less fat but end up having no nutritional benefits whatsoever.


<em>renee588</em>'s picture
fat free half and half???
by renee588 on January 11, 2006 - 6:17pm

It scares me to death to try, and then I was hooked. Because of the second ingredient, it is really great for all coffee, black tea, hot coco concontions. I even used it in scrambled eggs…tasted good. However, as a 2006 goal of less sugar its gotta go. —-But so did Coffee.


<em>Anonymous</em>'s picture
I'll stick to the regular 1/2 & 1/2...
by Anonymous on June 10, 2006 - 7:12pm
I like regular 1/2 & 1/2 but my mom likes the product featured here. I do like the fat free yogurt by Stonyfield (the others all have fake sugar) ========================= Check out Lime radio. Sirius Ch. 114 :)
<em>Anonymous</em>'s picture
please don't take my half & half away!
by Anonymous on June 12, 2006 - 6:01am
rich coffee & half & half in the am, gotta have it! (nothing compares) hey, I'm a skinny guy :-)
<em>Jeff58</em>'s picture
Not much better than wimpy skim milk
by Jeff58 on June 12, 2006 - 6:28am
Land O' Lakes Fat-Free Half and Half is okay. It doesn't enhance a cup of coffee much better than wimpy skim milk. It lacks the creaminess and buttery flavor of real half and half. I no longer buy the fat-free version.
<em>Anonymous</em>'s picture
It adds too much sweetness!
by Anonymous on June 12, 2006 - 7:57am
My boyfriend got me to start using the fat free half and half. I'm getting the Land O' Lakes brand and I really don't like it because it adds too much sweetness to my coffee. I never put any sugar in my coffee and I used to use the non-dairy creamers for years until one night I was having a coffee at a friends house and she had half and half. I realized right then that there was no going back to non-dairy. Now I only get half and half when I get my coffee at a Java Java store and it's such a treat. I really, really want to go back to having half and half at home.
<em>Anonymous</em>'s picture
Its a tough trade off
by Anonymous on June 12, 2006 - 8:35pm
The fat free half and half from Land O Lakes is too sweet for many things. I do use it in cream soups, but the corn syrup seems like your just trading one bad for another bad. We switched to organic skim and 1% milk recently. Wow, what a difference. I just wish I could find an organic half and half.
<em>Anonymous</em>'s picture
Organic half and half: found
by Anonymous on June 26, 2006 - 1:48am
Can find organic half and half? Here's an idea: buy organic milk and organic cream, and mix them. Remember, the obvious answer is usually the right one.
<em>Anonymous</em>'s picture
viewfan
by Anonymous on June 13, 2006 - 12:43pm
I like the mashed potato idea and will try!!
<em>Anonymous</em>'s picture
corn syrup is evil, milk fat is A-OK
by Anonymous on June 26, 2006 - 2:13am
This land o' lakes stuff sounds like heart disease and diabetes in a glass. Added sugar (corn syrup, same thing) in your milk? Milk naturally has a lot of sugar in it already, and sugar is way worse for you than fat. We found this out the hard way as our nation's kids got super fat and starting getting "adult onset" or type II diabetes as soon as the low fat fad diets came into play. Have we not learned? Drink whole milk in reasonable amounts and just be done with it. And please, look at the other ingredients in your fake dairy products. If there's anything but "milk" or "cream," don't buy them! Particularly evil ingredients to look out for are modified food starches and various gums (like guar), especially in low-fat yogurts, which are not only are bad for you but give things a horribly gloppy texture. Fat-free half and half is as illogical and as impossible, by definition, as a vegan who eats bacon. For your own health, please don't do it! If you must go no-fat, drink skim, not fake half and half. Eat fat-free dairy products made with skim milk, if you eat them at all, not with scary extra ingredients! Thank you!

User login


Join Lime Now, it's free