PrintEmail
Comment
Gotta Get the Lead Out, But the Arsenic's OK?
Posted by Kerry Trueman on April 6, 2006 - 8:33am.
files/images/prod/1263/logo.jpg

No more pollo con mole for me. First comes the news that 40,000 pounds of Dagoba organic chocolate had to be recalled after a laboratory in Oregon, where the company is based, confirmed that three kinds of Dagoba chocolate bars contained high levels of lead.

Then Marion Burros reported in yesterday's New York Times that much of the chicken being sold in this country contains arsenic, and, even more disturbing, that arsenic is a government-approved additive in poultry feed, where it's used to kill parasites and promote growth.

Frederick Schilling, president of Dagoba Organic Chocolate, has flown to Ecuador, the source of the tainted cocoa, to find out what went wrong. Dagoba promptly recalled the products in question: the Eclipse and Los Rios chocolate bars, and Prima Materia 2-pound cocoa bricks, used for cooking.

"This is an isolated situation and we take this matter extremely seriously and have taken immediate measures to remove all of these products from the marketplace as quickly as possible," Jeff Williams, chief operating officer of Dagoba, told the Mail Tribune of Medford, Oregon.

How did the lead get into the cocoa in the first place? Chocolate has some of the highest levels of lead contamination of any food we eat, which is why chocolate manufacturers routinely test for it. Cocoa beans can become contaminated from lead in the soil, water, or air, but studies suggest that contamination more likely occurs during processing. Scientists have found it difficult to isolate the source of lead contamination in chocolate.

And how does arsenic get into the chickens we eat? Arsenic's a known carcinogen, and many experts believe that there's no safe level of consumption, because the effects of arsenic are cumulative. In addition to potentially causing cancer, arsenic may contribute to diabetes, heart disease, and a decline in mental functioning. Small children and, not surprisingly, people who eat a lot of chicken, are at greatest risk.

The chicken industry defends the practice of feeding arsenic to chickens, and thus, to us. "We are not aware of any study that shows implications of any possibility of harm to human health as the result of the use of these products at the levels directed," Richard Lobb, spokesman for the National Chicken Council, told the New York Times.

But the FDA set the tolerance level for arsenic in chicken decades ago, and hasn't revised it despite the fact that chicken consumption in the U.S. has tripled since 1960. The USDA even admitted in a 2004 study that "higher than previously recognized levels of arsenic in chicken combined with increasing levels of chicken consumption may indicate a need to review assumptions regarding overall ingested arsenic intake."

While the FDA dithers, some poultry producers, including Tyson, have voluntarily stopped using arsenic in their chicken feed. McDonald's says it doesn't use chicken with arsenic, either. Chicken from "boutique" poultry producers such as Bell & Evans and Eberley contains no arsenic, and any chicken sold as organic or antibiotic-free should be arsenic-free, as well.

A study from the Institute for Agriculture and Trade Policy measured the levels of arsenic in chicken sold in supermarkets and fast food outlets, and found that the amount of arsenic varied considerably, but none of the chicken had unacceptable levels of arsenic by the FDA's antiquated standards.

The study found that Perdue chicken contained arsenic, and the company acknowledged that they do sometimes use chicken feed containing arsenic. Some samples from the gourmet food chain Trader Joe's tested positive, too. Trader Joe's had no comment.

Guess I'll think twice about buying Trader Joe's chicken maple sausages. My mental functioning is already endangered enough from all that mercury-tainted tuna. Sausage, I can live without. But sushi? No way.



Related Shop Items


<em>Leigh</em>'s picture
Lead ?!?
by Leigh on April 7, 2006 - 8:14am
I had no idea there was lead in chocolate, and the darker the chocolate the more lead you get? That's even worse. I wonder if they could sell “lead free” high octane chocolate bars? I guess white chocolate has no lead, but it also tastes like it has no chocolate. What to do…..
<em>kat</em>'s picture
I share your despair...
by kat on April 7, 2006 - 8:58am
...but don't do something so drastic as switching to white chocolate! It's not chocolate at all; no flavor, no flavanoids. Reputable chocolatiers do regularly test their chocolates for lead, and I think the Dagoba incident shows a commitment to keeping the contaminants out of our beloved dark chocolate. It's not in their interests to sell lead-laced chocolates, either!
<em>Anonymous</em>'s picture
Lead Home Test Kits
by Anonymous on April 7, 2006 - 5:24pm
It seems like we are coming to an era where we'll have to be armed with home hazard test kits to investigate our food before we eat it. It occurred to me that chocolate is probably consumed a lot by kids, and I wonder if a study has ever indicated chocolate affecting learning levels. Our general decline in population IQ could either indicate too much chocolate or too much television. Who knows. I am developing a (farcicial) point system whereby one can determine their risk of cancer daily. This information on lead and arsenic will certainly augment my tabulations.
<em>Amy_Rice</em>'s picture
Yuk, factory raised chickens are a nightmare!
by Amy_Rice on April 9, 2006 - 12:01pm
How could anyone eat factory raised chickens? They are disgusting! Arsenic is probably the least of their problems. They are walking cesspools of salmonella and they are treated worse than anything you could imagine. PETA has well documented the horrible conditions. Don't get me wrong, I love chicken but it has to be raised responsibly.

User login


Join Lime Now, it's free

Meet New People

DougMiller (View Profile)

Interests: Parenting (Jack 5yrs and Owen 3yrs), Human Growth and Development, Evolving Consciousness, Integral Life Practice, Coaching, Change Management, Creativity, and Freedom.
Inspiration: Witnessing my sons discovering the world and themselves, watching someone overcome all odds, listening to someone's deep dark secrets (and telling someone mine), a fully expressed performer, art, the rawness of humanity, and unconditional love.

More new members | Create your profile