PrintEmail
Comment
Walk Talk #11—When a Manhattanite Goes to Brooklyn
Posted by Walk Talk on April 24, 2007 - 8:04am.

When a Manhattanite goes to Brooklyn all the world will stare. They might laugh or jeer or spit, or they might applaud the isolated islander's brave new soul. Wait hold on, did you say spit? What cretins! Which neighborhood? Where?! First of all, a lady Manhattanite never tells. And second, a lady Manhattanite might consider telling if she had even the faintest idea as to her own whereabouts at any point during her epic Brooklyn weekend Walk Out.

 

It all started on a glorious 70-degree Saturday morning with an invitation to brunch in Brooklyn's Carroll Gardens. The unsuspecting lady (who never turns down a brunch) stepped out of her apartment with half an hour's time to make the journey-lesson number 1: always leave an hour's traveling time when coming from Manhattan's Upper West Side on your way into Brooklyn. Now because this particular lady can burn rubber (soles that is), she arrived only fifteen minutes late to a sumptuous feast prepared by two gracious hosts-lesson number 2: Brooklynites have bigger kitchens and they know how to use them.

 

Then she was off again, headed back to her island for a day of gallery hopping and Shake Shack-ing at Madison Square park on 23rd and 5th because yes, real ladies do eat at the Shake Shack. One nap and a belly rub later she was ready to go; this time, a walk across the Brooklyn Bridge. Underfoot, the wooden walkway spelled relief for her aching feet, while all around her lights in both boroughs were beginning to flicker on as the sun went slowly down. Standing below the massive stone arches her companions wondered aloud, "if the lady is three stones tall, how many lady's-tall is the arch?" Looking up was dizzying and they all lost count.

 

That night in Park Slope she enjoyed a restful sleep at the home of one lady Brooklynite-lesson number 3: less traffic noise in Brooklyn neighborhoods means undisturbed beauty sleep-and awoke on Sunday with a mind to find the Promenade. It was the kind of day for getting lost they decided, and let no misstep(s) befoul this first glorious high-70's-weather day. From Park Slope east through South Brooklyn, across the Gowanus River, north through Carroll Gardens, Cobble Hill and Brooklyn Heights, they walked along the Promenade on the East River ending up in Dumbo.

 

There munching a sandwich in the park under the Brooklyn Bridge, they and the other sunbathers and dogs witnessed a small wedding ceremony. While tourists wearing I Heart NY t-shirts clicked their cameras at the strangers our lady took off her shoes fell back into the grass and mused, "I Heart Brooklyn," that's lesson number 4.

 

Annie Costner

 

New York, NY



<em>Statuesqueone</em>'s picture
Confusing?
by Statuesqueone on April 24, 2007 - 3:18pm
Not really sure what this article is trying to get across. Is the author referring to a dog that is walking from Manhattan to Brooklyn? The only reason I think that is because of the belly run and the other dogs watching the wedding......I did like the New York references and the links that took me to pictures of New York. New York is a cool city and reading about someone enjoying walking it is cool.Am I the only one that didn't "get it?"
<em>Bob_From_Bklyn</em>'s picture
Very Confusing
by Bob_From_Bklyn on April 24, 2007 - 9:52pm
I too am confused by this.  I am also not pleased about the characterization of Brooklyn that is implied in the comment, "They might laugh or jeer or spit, or they might applaud the isolated islander's brave new soul. Wait hold on, did you say spit? What cretins!"  This sterotyping of Brooklynites as cretins is an extremely prejudicial and judgemental remark and the author should think more carefully before choosing her words.  
<em>jjackson</em>'s picture
In defense...
by jjackson on April 25, 2007 - 6:03am
The author is referring to an actual incident. She WAS spat at during her trip to Brooklyn. I myself am a proud Brooklynite, but what happened happened. I think she's stereotyping spitters as cretins more than Brooklynites, as in, "what cretins dare give Brooklyn a bad name?"

<em>gmark</em>'s picture
Whadaya Sayin'?
by gmark on April 25, 2007 - 8:53am

"what cretins dare give Brooklyn a bad name?"

What kinda joik tawks like dat?  No Brooklynites I eva hoid of.


<em>acos</em>'s picture
I heart Brooklyn
by acos on April 25, 2007 - 9:31am
Bob From Bklyn, it's true, someone did spit at me. And I was upset by it. Jjackson is right that I used the word cretins to stereotype spitters and not Brooklynites. Regardless, the article itself is very tongue-in-cheek; no one actually refers to me as "lady Manhattanite." Can you imagine? Finally Bob, I am a huge fan of Brooklyn and I think this article conveys my affections.
<em>Greenie</em>'s picture
Confusing Indeed
by Greenie on April 25, 2007 - 10:11am
Regardless of spitting or no spitting, this piece needs a good edit so what the writer is trying to say comes out. As is, it does not make sense and is not an editorially sound piece. Therein lies the confusion.
<em>Statuesqueone</em>'s picture
What about the dog?
by Statuesqueone on April 25, 2007 - 3:20pm
I agree with the author that it is very tongue-in-cheek, and quite entertainng (if not a bit confusing). I liked that she walked as much as she did and wrote to tell us about it, even if I was too thick skulled to figure it out. But is it really about a dog that gets it's belly rubbed?p.s. liked gmark's comment ;-) 
<em>Vicki_R</em>'s picture
walking is the point
by Vicki_R on April 25, 2007 - 3:22pm
O.K. the piece is a bit confusing, but who cares.  She walked for g-ds sake and isn't that the point anyway? The Walk Out is supposed to bring us all together, not make critics out of us.

<em>Bob_From_Bklyn</em>'s picture
OK - But I'm Still Confused
by Bob_From_Bklyn on April 25, 2007 - 7:13pm

Annie - I'm sorry to hear about your spitting incident.  That can indeed be rather disconcerting.  Now I do see that your final lesson for the day is "I Heart Brooklyn", which is something I've done my entire life.

But I'm still a little confused.  Was this 2 separate long walks?  Did you walk from the upper west side to Carroll Gardens, walk back to Madison Square Park, then back to Brooklyn to Park Slope and then to the park under the Brooklyn Bridge?  If you did, this was some long weekend of walking.  Were you walking a dog or do YOU enjoy belly rubs?   What kind of sandwich did you eat under the bridge?  Did you walk back to the upper west side from the Brooklyn Bridge park?  You leave us wanting to know more. Fill us in. 

 


User login


Join Lime Now, it's free