PrintEmail
Comment
Saying Adieu to My French Press
Posted by Su Avasthi on March 28, 2007 - 1:24pm.

A couple days ago, a friend emailed me an article in the New York Times about how various beverages affect our health.

I dutifully skimmed it, expecting to find the same old, same old. You know, water is good for us, soda is not, cut back on sugary drinks, and caffeine and alcohol are healthy in moderation.

But a few paragraphs down (and in parenthesis), I discovered a bombshell. Apparently, drinking coffee brewed in a French press -- as well as espresso machines -- raises cholesterol and harmful LDL levels.

Mais non! Say it ain't so.

A French press, also known as a press pot or coffee plunger, is my very favorite way to achieve the perfect cup of coffee. The flavor is yummier and the texture is thicker and more sediment-y (some of us appreciate this quality.) And apparently, the process leaves behind some essential oils.

And that is where the trouble starts. Unlike a drip machine, coffee made in a French press or espresso machine doesn't require a filter. As a result, chemical compounds, including Cafestol and Kahweol remain in the coffee, and seem to cause our cholesterol levels to spike. It seems that Cafestol is the most potent cholesterol-elevating compound known in the human diet. Great.

To a French press addict like myself, this is terrible news. After all, that humble coffeemaker is one of my favorite things in the world. It is, quite simply, one the reasons that I get out of bed in the mornings.

For years, I've loyally defended my French press, as the coffee snobs in my life who feel the need to upgrade to outrageously expensive coffeemakers.

The same loyalty sent me to Google the situation, just to see how dangerous this method really is. Unfortunately, what I found wasn't especially encouraging. Several sites, including MSNBC, Wikipedia, CoffeeGeek, and, of course, Lime.com note that the French press or European brewing methods are linked to higher cholesterol. Somehow, though, I'd never registered this information.

The silver lining is that people with low or average cholesterol rates probably don't have to worry much about this. Still, I'm not sure if I can have my potta joe if I cut back on eggs or other high-cholesterol foods.

The truth is, I refuse to put my favorite coffee pot on a high shelf. I might live a bit longer if I do that -- but I'll be too grumpy to enjoy the extra time.

Photo credit: CoffeeGeek

 



<em>jjackson</em>'s picture
Screw it.
by jjackson on March 29, 2007 - 7:14am

Cholesterol be damned. I will not give up espresso, or the French press stuff that my writing partner makes at his place. 

Cafestol, Kehweoul, or gasoline, I'm moving forward, full speed ahead.

I have been warned by a doctor about my cholesterol, and since then I've made a lot of changes, not all of them easy, but this is something I just will not do. You'll have to put me in a box first.

This is where I draw the line. 


<em>Vicki_R</em>'s picture
the real french paradox
by Vicki_R on March 29, 2007 - 7:14am
It's really interesting that the french have such a long lifespan and they drink both coffee and wine in excessive amounts.  I wonder if the flavanols in the wine counterbalance the toxins in the coffee?  Now that really is the french paradox?
<em>DrSlice</em>'s picture
The ultimate paradox!
by DrSlice on March 29, 2007 - 8:33am
Not to mention all the french toast and french fries they (presumably) eat.
<em>peabody</em>'s picture
pressing coffee issue
by peabody on March 29, 2007 - 9:42am
Whether it's hypertension, headaches or renal failure, coffee seems to be more harmful then helpful.  How it's brewed I can't see making a huge detrimental effect though, but the survey says differently.  Many things now a days apparently can raise cholesterol, ie: skipping meals as mentioned by Oz Garcia.  I will (like others) pursue to keep with my latte thus doubling up on the cholesterol and making it a tastier treat.  I think I'll even treat myself to an extra shot today!
<em>Vicki_R</em>'s picture
make it a soy latte
by Vicki_R on March 29, 2007 - 11:33am

It used to be thought that soy milk helped lower cholesterol, however in 2006 the FDA said the soy industry could not make that claim anymore with having discovered new evidence to the contrary. There goes my idea that you counterbalance the coffee by making it a soy latte!

 


<em>savasthi</em>'s picture
Still, it sounds a lot healthier
by savasthi on March 29, 2007 - 1:01pm
than trying to fight higher cholesterol levels with half-and-half that I currently use...
<em>Shay_Re</em>'s picture
FDA-shmef-DA
by Shay_Re on March 29, 2007 - 4:22pm
I wouldn't take everything that the FDA says to heart without second guessing them.....Let's not forget they are the ones who think that its ok to inject our food with chemicals, pesticides, and hormones....and that 3-5 servings of fruits and veggies is enough.  I beg to disagree, the French live long healthy lives because they live in moderation and actually move their bodies...so drink your coffee,with soy!  Not to mention the fact that the Chinese consume the highest amounts of soy and have the lowest rates of disease, just a few points to consider.
<em>Vicki_R</em>'s picture
best of both worlds
by Vicki_R on March 29, 2007 - 5:44pm
I am a half and half user mysel,f however I just bought a soy creamer yesterday.  The best of both worlds.
<em>dreamymo</em>'s picture
really surprising
by dreamymo on March 29, 2007 - 9:07pm
su - im with you - this is something i never saw coming, and like you im making the decision to stick with the press --but it does make you stop an think for sure
<em>founderofinfogatherer</em>'s picture
From a Frenchman himself...oui...
by founderofinfoga... on March 30, 2007 - 12:08am

You know, in France, we do not worry about cholesterol too much or fats, and bla,,,bla,,,bla,,,We live quite a long life and we seem to to get huge either...the key? Sure some natural genetics, I am sure, but the MAIN ingredient:

 

Good quality foods and ingredients  AND moderation...Same for coffee...Some studies shows now that it helps you not to have a heart attack, others that it can stress you..AGAIN...moderation...and, when we are at it, in France we start to boost bio wine (organic) and bio coffee too (at last) ...So, if you get organic coffee it is better too... I remarked that too may people trying for controling fats a lot and cholesterol etc...finish to become stressed, paranoid and tight...MODERATION...IS....the key...


<em>Vicki_R</em>'s picture
Ce la vie!!
by Vicki_R on March 30, 2007 - 10:02am

I agree wholoe-heartedly!!! Moderation is the key.  If you watch your diet and watch the other foods you eat, go ahead a live a little.  Life is way too short and skipping a good cup of joe is really a sin. 

Ce la vie!! ( don't know how to spell that, but you get the jist).


<em>vegan_kid</em>'s picture
Coffee zaps iron?
by vegan_kid on March 30, 2007 - 12:38pm

I love my french press, but I've cut waaaaay back on my coffee intake (2-3 cups a week vs 2-3 cups a day). 

 

Apparently, coffee zaps our iron?  The last time I went to donate blood, the drop didn't even bob in the copper sulfate solution.  It just sat there on the top.  I eat loads of green veggies and iron-fortified goodies, plus take supplemental iron.  I was WAY confused!!  Then the guy asked if I'm a coffee drinker, and told me to quit. 

 

Hmph.

 

As far as cholesterol, why not have a bowl of oatmeal with the coffee in the morning?  All those ads about people lowering their cholesterol 17 and 24 points in thirty days have to mean something!


<em>Magistra40</em>'s picture
Say it Ain't So!
by Magistra40 on March 30, 2007 - 4:53pm

I drink only 2 cups of coffee a day.  I drink organic, fairly traded, Arabica coffee.  I am NOT giving up my press!  Life is just too damn short.  I also have a "normal range" lipid profile!

 

As it was once said on "Saturday Night Live's" news broadcast:  "This just in.  Saliva has now been proven to cause cancer, but only if swallowed in small amounts over long periods of time."  Nothing is safe - or sacred - anymore.


<em>Vicki_R</em>'s picture
good old drips
by Vicki_R on April 2, 2007 - 3:00pm
Good sense of humor.  The article said french press coffee, not all coffee, so drink away, just bring out those old drips.  
<em>Lycas7x</em>'s picture
fresh coffee
by Lycas7x on April 6, 2007 - 7:10pm
 i've been told that coffee consumed days after its roasted is wonderful.  Its like sweet corn.  Its suppose to be super fresh and they dont sell it that way in stores,   I haven't tried it yet but somebody told me to go to  www.coffeefool.com maybe it doesn't matter how you make it then.
<em>Vicki_R</em>'s picture
try ti
by Vicki_R on April 10, 2007 - 3:43pm
Love the site.  There is a local company where I live that roast there own coffee called www.smallworld.com.  It actually has the date it was roasted on.  It is wonderful except very expensive, about $5.00 more than conventional starbucks.  I splurge sometimes and yes, it is wonderful, so go ahead and try it.

<em>worldinsoftWW</em>'s picture
by worldinsoftWW on April 25, 2009 - 5:42pm
sss
<em>shaani</em>'s picture
Love
by shaani on October 22, 2009 - 6:14am

I like it gooo

visit

http://www.srt.com.pk


<em>jesonkk</em>'s picture
Today, more and more people
by jesonkk on January 11, 2010 - 12:33am
Today, more and more people wear eyeglasses , it is not only helpful to the role of vision, it also has decorative effect, Hence we have popular mens eye glass frames. Everyone wants to be able to buy cheap eyewear, and I recommend everyone to firmoo to buy, where there are many types of discount perscription eyeglasses,they also offer bifocal glasses, very cheap. I bought a pair of eye glasses frames to my grandma. More about $20 eyeglass frames .8tui
<em>jesonkk</em>'s picture
escort and massage shanghai
by jesonkk on January 17, 2010 - 9:00pm
escort and massage shanghai business information consultation our girls C who are office executives. Best online sex toys and adult toy store for man, woman,. Dragonfly's Japan tour is led by guides who are passionate about their country and want to share it with you.75859
<em>jesonkk</em>'s picture
Purchasing prescriptions
by jesonkk on January 21, 2010 - 10:02pm
Purchasing prescriptions glasses online is much convenient than at optical stores. We just need to visit the website of an online vendor and then select what we love. After that,http://eyecare.twoday.netwe can order the goods, pay for those products and wait for the delivery.http://visionhealth.unblog.fr That’s the whole process of purchasing prescriptions glasses online.7youyoyup

User login