PrintEmail
Comment
An Inconvenient Backlash
Posted by Su Avasthi on March 13, 2007 - 3:42pm.

Sure, there are still a few scientists -- most of whom seem to have ulterior motives -- who continue to deny global warming.

But the vast majority of climate experts agree that our planet is getting hotter. However, some climatologists -- who claim that they have "no axe to grind" -- say that Gore exaggerated facts and statistics in his Oscar-winning documentary, An Inconvenient Truth.

According to an article in the New York Times, many of these "rank-and-file" scientists are questioning whether Gore’s central points are exaggerated and erroneous. And lot of them are saying -- via talks, papers, and blogs -- that the picture presented by Gore was "too alarmist."

Gore responded to the Times' questions, saying that the movie made “the most important and salient points” about climate change, if not “some nuances and distinctions” that the scientists might want to see. He added that he tried to communicate scientific points to the lay-person.

For those of us with a green streak may feel a bit conflicted after hearing this news.

On the one hand, the movie and its central arguments have raised public awareness about global warming, climate change, and especially the responsibility that each of us has to reduce our carbon footprint. That sense of alarm is a real motivator -- well, it motivates me to separate my plastics for recycling and walk to the grocery store, rather than hop in my car.

On the other hand, I'm fairly sure that the movie failed to present scientific facts with 100 percent accuracy. Let's face it: I don't care if the ice sheets have melted by .25 inches or .5 inches or whatever. I just care that they're melting. In that sense, I can accept Gore's point that the specifics -- in many ways -- aren't important to the lay person.

I'm glad that the experts are around to parse out the specifics, analyze the data, and provide corrections as needed. It's their job to make sense of the details, and naturally that entails some arguments. Meanwhile, I still only care about the big picture.

As it turns out, most scientists find themselves in the middle when it comes to climate change. They're somewhere between the kooks who continue to deny the impact of global warming and the zealots who are marching around with a "The World Is Coming To An End" sign. And the middle is pretty much where I find myself too.



Global warming
by skupe on March 14, 2007 - 11:52am

I think that there are so many people who still aren't acknowleging it that it's good that Gore scares them into doing something.

Look at all the SUVs still on the road.  So many people don't seem to care.  They just want what they want.   So I say let him terrify people into action.  It's a shame it has to be this way.

 

It's the same reason why so many people in the world are obese until they are told they better do saomething or die.

 

Suz


<em>inaiyana</em>'s picture
WATCH THIS VIDEO - IT IS A MUST
by inaiyana on March 14, 2007 - 5:30pm

.......As for Al Gore (the inventor of the internet) movie the 'Inconvenient Truth' - view the segment in the video starting at 20 minutes running through 24 minutes. You'll discover the inconvenient truth about Al's 'facts'. ....

 

http://www.dare2baware.com/article/6136/the_great_global_warming_swindle

 

www.home-schooling-uk.com www.dare2baware.com www.shamanicjourney.com www.fun-travels.com


<em>Elizabeth_Borelli</em>'s picture
It's Easy to Criticize...
by Elizabeth_Borelli on March 14, 2007 - 5:49pm
Global warming is inherently connected to the issue of sustainability.  The exact rate at which either of these events is happening is somewhat irrelevant - the fact is that the planet cannot support our current rate of waste and consumption, and future  generations are going to pay the price for that, whether through  polluted air and  oceans, loss many of the resources we take for granted and many of our animal species, etc.  How can you not care about that, especially if you have kids?  If Gore wasn't 100 % accurate in some of the details of the movie, who cares?  The point is that  he's attempting to raise awareness, in spite of unwarranted criticism and character attack.  I'd love to see these critics actually put themselves on the line trying to make this kind of a difference and see how easy it is.    www.nubiusorganics.com
<em>granolagirl</em>'s picture
truth or not
by granolagirl on March 14, 2007 - 7:33pm
If making people afraid is what it takes to get them to make a change for the better in the way they use this planet......then so be it!

<em>cherylanne</em>'s picture
awareness
by cherylanne on March 14, 2007 - 10:02pm
i felt this movie  showed me  that i  have a responsibility  to protect my home i call Earth.  It's like Al Gore said "hmmm, which would i choose, all the gold bars or the Earth?"   not too difficult a choice for me either.  keep your money  let me care for the Earth .. my home..  my dream.. my love...  my responsibility .. ! 
<em>phiggs</em>'s picture
not to bust your bubble...
by phiggs on March 14, 2007 - 10:39pm

But William Broad has been pretty solidly criticized throughout the scientific and journalism communities over the past few days for painting an inaccurate picture of the scientists he cites as critical of Gore's project. For the most part they are not, as he suggests, mainstream or centrist; they are widely known for their relatively extreme views of climate change. For a good point-by-point rebuttal of Broad's article, click here, or go to realclimate.org, a highly respected climate science blog, which also took Broad to task for his story.

 Most scientists are not, in fact, "in the middle" of the climate change (so-called) debate, but firm believers. 


<em>Vicki_R</em>'s picture
death threats
by Vicki_R on March 15, 2007 - 10:55am

On monday I read an article on LIME that said scientists were getting death threats for spreading the word on global warming.  What has this world come to?

 


<em>tonyome</em>'s picture
Catastrophic Global Warming is a Myth
by tonyome on March 20, 2007 - 1:22pm
I am becoming increasingly uncomfortable with the pressure being put on those of us who feel that the global warming hysteria is largely a myth.  The latest tactic being used by some groups is that anyone who denys global warming is the same as people "denying the Holocaust".  This is ridiculous.  The facts are, there have been countless periods of warming and cooling in the history of this planet, when people weren't even here.  How can we, in our arrogance, say that we are "causing" global warming when there is so much about our world and the cycles that occur in it that we don't even understand?  Remember when Al Gore said that we were going to have a disasterous hurricane season last year?  It didn't happen.  So they can't predict the weather a few months in advance, but now they are going to tell us what the sea level is going to be in a hundred years?  Face reality people.

User login


Join Lime Now, it's free