PrintEmail
Comment
Paper or Plastic?
Posted by Su Avasthi on November 13, 2006 - 7:43pm.

The other day, I stopped by the organic supermarket in my neighborhood to grab a few groceries for the week. As I waited in the checkout line, I noticed that the lady ahead of me had brought along a canvas tote to lug her groceries home with minimal environmental damage.

I glanced over at the next checkout aisle and saw a scruffy-looking young couple who radiated patchuoli and vegan goodness. They also had enough foresight to bring in a couple of mesh bags.

"You saved 25 cents today ma'am," the cashier told the lady in front on me, as he packed her groceries in her tote. The two of them exchanged a warm, we're-doing-right-by-the-planet smile and then the woman looked over to study a sign by the door.

I'm in this store a few times a week, but this was the first time I noticed a huge poster by registers, reminding shoppers to bring their own bags. If you B.Y.O.B., you'll save a little spare change and if you want, you can donate the change to your the charity of your choice.

"Donate my quarter to the Nature Conservancy," she said, with just enough self-satisfaction to make me jealous.

Then, it was my turn at the register. "Paper or plastic?" asked the cashier. Was it my imagination, or did he shoot me a "geez, you sure are wasteful" smirk as he asked the question?

"Uhh," I stammered, as I frantically tried to remember which one did less damage to the environment. "Paper, I guess?" I told him, sounding not at all sure of myself.

Later, when I got home, I Googled paper and plastic, and learned that I had picked the worst offender. Both paper and plastic are bad for the environment, considering that both wind up in landfills and take years (if not centuries) to breakdown. Still, it truly is a debatable issue.

In the final analysis, however, plastic bags seem to be slightly better for the planet. Producing them consumes 40 percent less energy and generates 80 percent less solid waste than paper bags. Plastic bags can also be recycled easily, by returning them to the grocery store. Reusing any bags (or going without, when possible) can have a dramatic impact on the environment; We use way too many bags.

The whole experience convinced me to stash a couple canvas totes in the backseat of my car. That way, the next time I'm in the checkout line, I'll B.Y.O.B and maybe sound a little smug when I tell the cashier to donate my change. Who knows, maybe it'll inspire some other unsuspecting schmuck to bring their own bags, too.



<em>organiczen</em>'s picture
wow!
by organiczen on November 14, 2006 - 9:09am

Organiczen-Glow from the outside in!

I have always chosen paper where available thinking it was the better choice for the enviroment.  Well, I feel like the shmuck too.  Next time I go to the health food store, it will be to purchase some canvas bags!


<em>Luck_Factory</em>'s picture
Diapers and bags
by Luck_Factory on November 14, 2006 - 11:05am

I was wondering abou this, too.  When we had a baby around, we need loads of bags to handle the diaper disposal (yes, disposable diapers.  Sorry.).  Now that he's toile trained we are pout of the habit of bring our own bags to the store and we're drowning in bags.  thanks for the reminder!

 

Luck Factory

http://www.luckfactory.com


<em>dreamymo</em>'s picture
worried in the past too
by dreamymo on November 14, 2006 - 1:36pm

now ive fully stocked up since i got some new canvas bags at this past weekends greenfestival (www.greenfestivals.org) - everyone was giving some out.


<em>Terri_K</em>'s picture
I use canvas
by Terri_K on November 14, 2006 - 3:13pm

 I picked up about 10 canvas bags at a thrift store a few months ago to use for grocery shopping.  What used to take a dozen or more plastic bags, I can now fit in 5 or 6 canvas.  Less waste, less trips to the trunk.  Most clerks look at me like I'm a bit crazy when I say I brought my own bags, but I feel it's the best choice.

 

No one thought up being;

He who thinks he has

Step forward.  - Jim Morrison


<em>lifegoeson</em>'s picture
trash
by lifegoeson on November 14, 2006 - 7:58pm
kathleenI have the cloth bags, but what do we use now for our trash bags? What do we use for cat litter disposal??? Sometimes I get plastic bags at the grocery store just for this purpose. There must be a better way to collect our trash???
<em>prismamoon</em>'s picture
Living without the bags
by prismamoon on January 12, 2007 - 1:31pm
Here's an idea for you. If you sew at all you can easily make some nifty cloth bags out of unused tee shirts (boy is my husband good for that!). Cut off the sleeves, hem, then sew up the bottom! Since they're made from tee shirts they fold up really small and can be stowed in a purse until you get to the register. I guess I'm one of those people who feels kind of silly stuffing armloads of mesh bags in my cart, so I thought up this solution. It recycles old clothes and keeps me from using plastic or paper!As for the trash and cat litter thing, well this may not work if you live in an apartment or anything, but we use pure clay litter (which is 100% natural and biodegradable, plus it's the cheapest on the shelf) then we dump it in the woods, varying our location so we don't concentrate it in one spot, giving it the chance to disperse. If they were wild they would "go" there anyway and the clay litter makes no impact, so we feel better about doing that than we would about bagging and trashing it. For apartment living I've heard of flushable litter. I don't know what it's made of, though. 

User login


Join Lime Now, it's free

Meet New People

milkyway (View Profile)

Interests: Practicing DJing, Feng Shui, Spirituality, Candle and Soap making, Yoga, Camping, Bicycling, Movies, Music
Inspiration: Music. Nature.

More new members | Create your profile