PrintEmail
Comment
True or False: Fish Is Brain Food
Posted by Su Avasthi on April 26, 2007 - 4:30am.

Here's a brain-teaser.

Technically, eating lots of fish should make us smarter. But how smart is it to eat a lot of PCB- and mercury-laden fish?

I got to thinking about this a couple mornings ago, when I caught a Today Show teaser while making my morning coffee. In a pre-java daze, I heard Matt Lauer chirp: "Is fish really brain food? We'll find out right after this commercial break." Before I could find out, however, I got distracted and forgot to listen to the answer.

I now blame this lapse in concentration on (what else?) not eating enough fish. So, after fueling up at lunch with a spicy tuna roll, I decided to tackle the question for myself.

A quick search online revealed that there's lots of research to back up the claim that eating fish does indeed benefit our brains. The magic, as you probably know, comes from omega-3 fatty acids found in oily fish like salmon, tuna, sardines, herring, mackerel, and others varieties. It seems that one of omega-3s—DHA—can help strengthen brain cells and protect them from disease.

But these days, aren't we all a bit wary of fish? It's impossible to ignore all that talk about mercury, PCBs, and other environmental contaminants. The fact is, my sushi habit has dwindled considerably, which may be why I'm more tuned into Brangelina than Barak Obama.

Clearly, it's time to find other ways to feed my head; I'll take any brain-boosting I can get now that I'm limiting my intake of fish.

So I started poking around, and came across several articles about other foods that are believed to help our brains function better. The good news is that a reasonably healthy diet goes a long way.

  • Flax and walnut seed oils are thought to be the next best thing to fish oils. Plus, they're a good fallback for vegetarians and anyone else who's unwilling to eat fish several times a week.
  • If your memory is starting to falter, antioxidant-rich fruits and vegetables, like blueberries, blackberries, and carrots might help you remember where you left your keys.
  • Eggs, red meats, and peanut butter have choline, which is also thought to enhance memory.
  • Whole grains — high in vitamin B and magnesium — are good for nerve function.
  • Tumeric, the intensely yellow spice used to color Indian curries, could have anti-inflammatory powers.

So, tomorrow I'll make toss some blueberries into my oatmeal. Or sprinkle some turmeric on my next egg salad sandwich.

Then I'll sit back and wait for my IQ to soar to new heights... or at least for the moment when celebrity gossip starts to seem downright trivial.



<em>Anonymous</em>'s picture
salmon is the answer
by Anonymous on September 29, 2006 - 10:10am
not only does it help your brain but it keeps you younger....
<em>Vicki_R</em>'s picture
six feet under
by Vicki_R on April 26, 2007 - 7:31am

Just be careful with peanut butter and make sure it is organic.  Peanuts are the most heavily sprayed crop with pesticides.  And no matter how good your brain may  be, it can't help if you are six feet under!

 


<em>loryjean</em>'s picture
don't believe everything you read...
by loryjean on April 26, 2007 - 4:28pm
This article mentions, appropriately, that there is conflict over whom to believe in the fish vs. no fish issue. Contamination levels not only vary widely, but they can also occur in processing, regardless of where the fish were caught. There is also disparity in how those levels are calculated and presented by various "interest" groups. Many of the scare tactics used inflate the risk, while others would tell you there is none. Use common sense, try to get as pure a product as you can, but don't eliminate an essential food just because "someone" has a "statistic" that sounds dangerous.
<em>loisjean</em>'s picture
fish or no fish
by loisjean on April 26, 2007 - 5:31pm
lois mcvicker if we are not care ful with our lakes and waterways we may all be dead in 100 years.
<em>swati</em>'s picture
Take a pill
by swati on April 26, 2007 - 10:20pm
How about taking salmon oil pills?  I do that to control my trigylcerides and help my joints.  I have no idea if there's any mercury risk.  Guess I'm not smart enough to figure that out.  Hmm . . . maybe the pills aren't working.
<em>Statuesqueone</em>'s picture
Genuine concerns
by Statuesqueone on April 26, 2007 - 10:39pm
I am one that believes there are dangerous levels of mercury and other contaminants in fish, especially farm raised fish. I learned of biological magnification years ago in a geography class in college and quit eating fish that day. Since then I have read quite a bit about contaminated fish and try to make more educated choices when buying fish now that I started eating it again.
Fish is healthy and a nice alternative for those of us who don't eat red meat or pork. Come on, you can only eat chicken and ground turkey so many nights a week (especially when your husband isn't interested in meatless dishes).
I really appreciated Su Avasthi's recommendations for alternatives to eating fish. Seems like the smart thing to do!
And Swati, I never thought that my fish oil capsules may have mercury in them, hmmmm.......
<em>Harley</em>'s picture
reputable fish monger
by Harley on April 30, 2007 - 11:29am

The controversy continues.  The advantages of eating fish rich in omega 3 fatty acids makes me take the time to buy my fish at reputable fish mongers.  I don't mind spending some extra money if I feel comfortable in purchasing it.  You can never by 100% sure of where something comes from, but we can only do so much.

Can you get the same benefits from fish capsules as you do from actually eating fish? 


<em>Statuesqueone</em>'s picture
Those fish capsules
by Statuesqueone on April 30, 2007 - 3:24pm
I always thought fish oil capsules had the same benefits as eating the fish itself. I should probably do a bit more research on this. Much easier to swallow a pill than cook the fish. 
I also share with my cat as she has dry skin, it seems to help her. Has anyone heard that this could be bad for her?
<em>Vicki_R</em>'s picture
seems to be fine
by Vicki_R on May 1, 2007 - 4:23pm

It seems from my research, that taking capsules is as good as eating fish.  The reason harley may be concerned is that eating fruits for their antioxidants is the way to go to get the best results.  Certain foods you need to consume in their natural state, it seems, fish is not one of them.

There was one article that said that the oil is only as good as the fish it comes from.  Have you heard anything about this? 

 


<em>trinity8</em>'s picture
I love Sushi
by trinity8 on May 5, 2007 - 3:02pm

I also have had "mixed feelings" about eating fresh fish or even farmed fish (which is to be said to be the worst as for the food it is fed on). We eat fish at least once a week and that includes Sushi. After some research I found that it is perfectly fine to eat fish. You mention  all of the below.......

Flax and walnut seed oils .

antioxidant-rich fruits and vegetables,

Eggs, red meats, and peanut butter have choline, which is also thought to enhance memory.

Whole grains

Tumeric, the intensely yellow spice used to color Indian curries, could have anti-inflammatory powers.

 

Have you ever considered that the above could have side effects? Cause Allergies? Or even be 'pumped up' with Antibiotics and hormones? How about going organic and skipping the red meat?

 

viola www.dare2baware.com www.shamanicjourney.com www.home-schooling-uk.com www.fun-tavels.com


<em>Vicki_R</em>'s picture
trust
by Vicki_R on May 7, 2007 - 11:18am

Red meat is fine if the animals have fed on pesticide free grass and not been given hormones.  I try and by my beef at a reputable place like Whole Foods.  I trust there suppliers and have had only good experiences. 

I was concerned with sushi, so I did some research as well.  It seems that many restaurants flash freeze there fish to kill off bacteria.  It is really important that you trust your sushi makers and how they process there fish.  No one wants parasites.


User login


Join Lime Now, it's free

Meet New People

AutumnElayne (View Profile)

Interests: Indie Crafting, Art, Astronomy, Physics, History, Eco-Friendly, Computer Graphics, Sewing, Knitting, Drawing, Macrame, Painting, Spinning,Book Binding, Screenprinting, Electronics Tinkering, Web Design, Books about my interests, Coffee, Travel, Black Tea, Cooking, Corduroy, Wool Felt, Ribbons, Vintage Patches, Collecting Sanrio paraphernalia, Boondoggle, Zines
Inspiration: Carl Sagan, Jim Henson, and Tori Amos.

More new members | Create your profile