PrintEmail
Comment
CFLs: Risk vs. Reward
Posted by Su Avasthi on September 2, 2008 - 12:18am.

Remember that old saying: "No good deed goes unpunished?"

I got a harsh taste of that earlier this week, thanks to a compact flourescent light bulb. Like most everyone with a green streak, I replaced my regular lightbulbs with eco-friendly CFLs long ago.  

But I'm considering switching back to the regular bulbs after a CFL broke in my hand.

It happened when the lamp on my nightstand started to flicker. As I reached over to the bulb to make sure that it was properly seated, the bulb shattered against my palm. Glass shards, a mysterious white powder and — worst of all — mercury fell all over the nightstand, as well as on my pillows and bed.

The first thing I did was make sure that the glass didn't puncture my skin (fortunately, it didn't draw any blood.) The second thing I did was pick up the larger pieces of glass, grab a broom and start sweeping up the glass fragments and powder. As I was collecting them in a dustpan, I remembered that CFLs contain mercury.

A quick search on the web revealed that hovering over a broken CFL bulb is exactly what NOT to do. Broken CFLs release mercury gas into the air. The bulbs contain roughly five miligrams (about the size of a period at the end of a sentence) of mercury, which is a neurotoxin that shouldn't be ingested or inhaled.

Unfortunately, I cleaned up, rather than doing what the experts recommend: Open the windows and evacuate the area for at least 15 minutes. 

That said, however, it is hard to find reliable information about dealing with broken CFLs. The advice I found ranged from dismissing the risks of broken CFLs entirely to spending upwards of $5,000 to clean up a hazmat scene.

Perhaps the most reliable information comes from the EPA, which suggests that people ventilate the area and stay clear of it for at least 15 minutes. Afterwards, clean the glass and powder without using a vacuum or broom to prevent spreading mercury through the air. More details are available at their website. It's also important to dispose of CFLs correctly.

Meanwhile, the risks of mercury exposure seem to be higher for small children and pregnant women. I'm certainly not an expert, but it seems reasonable to use a regular lightbulb in kids' rooms or if you're expecting.

Personaly, I'll keep using CFLs for all overhead lighting, but I'm going back to regular bulbs for table lamps. It may not be green, but I'd rather limit my exposure to mercury. 



<em>jride</em>'s picture
Hello, LEDs!
by jride on September 2, 2008 - 12:18pm
You could try LED bulbs. Although they're a bit on the expensive side, they're even more energy efficient than CFLs, they last super long and they don't have the same disposal issues.
<em>jpgmarks</em>'s picture
I am with you all the way
by jpgmarks on September 2, 2008 - 12:45pm

I am with you all the way - although we've decided to nix CFLs throughout our home, after having one pop, go out, and smoke in our bathroom.  In a household with a toddler, I just don't feel like they are safe!  We have also had plenty of them burn out in less than a year, so I don't buy the super-long-lasting hype.

We will definitely be watching the LED technology as it develops & emerges.


<em>Kim.D</em>'s picture
CFLs as hazardous waste
by Kim.D on September 2, 2008 - 3:46pm

We had this same issue when my nephew broke a bulb. Clearing the area--especially of children is great advice. It's also important to dispose of these bulbs as hazardous waste rather than sending them straight to the trash or trying to recycle the glass.

I understand that CFLs last longer when they are left on. We shorten their lives by continually switching them on and off (as you would want to do to save energy - go figure). I think LED is a good idea but it's also about time for someone to build a better, non-toxic, warm light, affordable light bulb. Anyone for a movement?

 


<em>Kamil</em>'s picture
In selecting the right bulb
by Kamil on July 20, 2009 - 1:17am
In selecting the right bulb for your projector lamp, it is best that you read the gadget manual first to know if there are any specifications as to what type of bulb is required. Go over the manual carefully to see if there are any further instructions and suggestions on how to replace the bulb and what brand or type best suits the model of your projector.projector bulbs
<em>rahulraikwar24</em>'s picture
One night a few years back
by rahulraikwar24 on August 31, 2009 - 12:31am

One night a few years back I visited a friend's apartment, always cute and charming in the light of day. Something was, how shall I say, different.

Obsolete Electronic Components
<em>tradekey2006</em>'s picture
Risk and Reward always
by tradekey2006 on December 10, 2009 - 10:49pm

Risk and Reward always challenging!

bike parts

wood doors

barn doors

 


<em>smallstrong</em>'s picture
ferh46 We have been
by smallstrong on December 27, 2009 - 1:27am

ferh46

We have been selling prom dress, evening gown, Formal gown,Homecoming gown,Bridesmaid gown,Prom gown for over 15 years wedding dresses evening dresses cocktail dresses formal gowns prom dresses Prom dresses, prom and graduation. With tons of prom advice, designer dresses and gowns, and How-to prom information. wedding dresses wedding shop ed hardy Suppliers of Evening Dresses, Prom Dresses, Ball Gowns, Dynasty Dresses, Bridesmaid and Flower Girl Dresses in regular or Plus size.


<em>jesonkk</em>'s picture
Recently in the search
by jesonkk on January 8, 2010 - 1:20am
Recently in the search cheap eyeglass frames, a friend recommended me a web site on the glasses: firmoo.com.it has a number of glasses frames, discount eyeglassesand looks very beautiful. I bought a pair of bifocal reading glassesto my grandma. It makes me feel so surprised that they also provide cheap eyeglasses virtual try onftru
<em>jesonkk</em>'s picture
escort and massage shanghai
by jesonkk on January 14, 2010 - 9:58pm
escort and massage shanghai business information consultation our girls C who are office executives, orshanghai escort to indulge you in the wildest fantasies at the comfort and privacy of your hotel room or home. Best online sex toys and adult toy store for man, woman, .Dragonfly's Japan tour are led by guides who are passionate about their country and want to share it with you..67976yuouyp
<em>jesonkk</em>'s picture
This structure differs
by jesonkk on January 21, 2010 - 9:52pm

This structure differs considerably from full-frame and semi-rimless designs. From these two designs, an eyeglass frame can be seen more or less. http://firmooglass.wordpress.comThe name of full-frame eyeglasses suggests that there is a full frame goes around the lenses,http://fmjsir6.gujaba.comholding them stably.

g5rr

User login