PrintEmail
Comment
Excuse Me, Your Fat Is Contagious
Posted by Su Avasthi on July 26, 2007 - 1:06am.

Silly me. For years, I've mistakenly believed that I was responsible for my eating habits.

After all, no one forces me to eat poorly, over-indulge in high-fat foods, or skip a workout or three. Therefore, I assumed that any foolish choices are simply my own fault. But, in fact, the real culprit has been my friends. At least, that's the word from the experts (or alleged experts, anyway) who believe that it's our friends—not ourselves— who make us fat.

According to a new report in the New England Journal of Medicine, obesity is socially contagious, and it spreads from friend to friend.

If your friends are obese, then you are at much greater risk of becoming obese too, according to a team of medical sociologists who tracked the social networks of some 12,000 people over the course of about 30 years.

They found that if one person became obese, their friends were 57 percent more likely to do the same. And if a friend lost weight, then chances were higher that they'd drop some pounds as well.

In fact, the experts found that our friends' lifestyles are far more likely to influence our weight than the eating habits of our siblings or spouses.

In a broad sense, I do understand their point. Our environment definitely affects how and what we eat. For instance, If my lunch companions make five trips all-you-can-eat buffet, experts suspect that I'd be more likely to do the same.

Then again, during the past few years, I've watched several friends lose weight, some as much as 45 pounds. (Sadly, they didn't infect me with an improved eating and exercise regime.) Other friends have seen the scale creep steadily upwards over the years. (My scale is resists budging—up or down.)

Now, I've never had a paper published in a venerable medical journal, nor have I spent 30-odd years tracking complex social networks. In other words, I'm not qualified to say that this study strikes me as more bunk science.

However, I have spent about 30-odd years managing my weaknesses for pepperoni pizza or chocolate cupcakes. I've learned to control these cravings, but I can't banish them entirely.

If put any stock in this study—which I just can't seem to do—then the healthiest thing I could is to immediately drop my heavy friends and seek out only super-skinny people from now on.

Of course, the problem is that all my super-skinny new friends would end up dropping me. And who could blame them? They'd just catch my craving for pizza or cupcakes.



<em>gmark</em>'s picture
The Tipping Point
by gmark on July 26, 2007 - 10:38am

Anyone who has read Malcolm Gladwell's The Tipping Point knows that "epidemics" of behavior are a very real phenomenon. I'm not surprised that this would be true of obesity as well.

On the other hand, the New England Journal of Medicine is also reporting this week that psychic cats are predicting people's deaths:

http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20070725/ap_on_fe_st/death_cat

...so maybe they're just putting out their April Fool's issue a bit late this year.


<em>taradawn</em>'s picture
Generalizations....
by taradawn on July 26, 2007 - 11:42am
With studies like this, I think it's important to keep in mind that they are generalizations and do not apply to everyone, nor will they ever. I think there is stock to be put in this study, and I salute you a great job on taking control of your own eating habits... not everyone has that kind of willpower. 
Our eating and diet is a behavior, specifically a psychological behavior, and with the influence of our friends (not family, like the study said) plays a substantial role in how we choose to behave. I'm not surprised at all of the conclusions this study has drawn. I dont, however, believe everyone should drop thier obese friends. It just goes to show it's easier to lose (or gain) in groups. 
<em>Monmac1</em>'s picture
I have noticed
by Monmac1 on July 26, 2007 - 2:33pm

I do believe that somebody friends weight can alter theirs also. I have notice in the past couple of days that my roommates and dad are getting more health conscious of what they eat. They all know about my 30 Day Challenge and somewhat support me of what I am trying to do. Also since I have been taking a lot of walks lately they kind of just join me whenever I go out. They too have lost weight by just participating in my life, my lifestyle.


<em>Ecobabe</em>'s picture
Hard to say
by Ecobabe on July 26, 2007 - 3:29pm
I read this story this morning in the paper and it does make sense, to some degree. I was relating how when my husband and I go over to friends houses to play cards for the night we nosh all night, something we would never do at home by ourselves. Not that our friends are obese (okay so most of them are a bit over weight) but they do eat differently than we do. 

I also think genes have a major say in our bodies. My Dad is tall and thin as is my sister and I. My brother takes after my Mom a bit, heavy in the mid-section. My brother tends to eat more like our Mom, sweets and fats, whereas my sister and I eat more like our Dad, healthier. 

Not sure if we will ever know what the root causes of obesity are. I just know that we need to do something about it and we can do something about it. Eat healthier, exercise, and encourage our friends to do the same!
<em>Vicki_R</em>'s picture
comfort in friends
by Vicki_R on July 26, 2007 - 6:46pm
I actually think that there may be some truth to the article.  I know that people like to surround themselves with people that make them feel comfortable.  I seem to indulge more when I am with people who like to indulge as well.  When I am with more health concious friends, I refrain from eating the dessert or overeating.  But then again, there is more to friendship than what you look like. 
<em>not_bob18</em>'s picture
Sarah () () < |____|
by not_bob18 on July 27, 2007 - 7:42pm
Sarah () () < |____|
<em>not_bob18</em>'s picture
title
by not_bob18 on July 27, 2007 - 7:46pm

oops my bad!

I do think fat is contagious. I used to think that when you get fat, it's because of you. Not your peeps!

SARAH

not_bob189

not_bob18


User login


Join Lime Now, it's free

Meet New People

milkyway (View Profile)

Interests: Practicing DJing, Feng Shui, Spirituality, Candle and Soap making, Yoga, Camping, Bicycling, Movies, Music
Inspiration: Music. Nature.

More new members | Create your profile