PrintEmail
Comment
My Search For A Safer Water Bottle
Posted by Su Avasthi on June 4, 2007 - 10:34pm.

I've got a lovely collection of polycarbonate Nalgene water bottles in an array of colors: sunshine yellow, rosy red, smoke blue, and, my personal favorite, a light greenish-aqua.

It's no exaggeration to say that one of these is always within easy reach, whether it's in my gym bag, on my desk, attached to my bike, sloshing around in my slouchy purse, or beside my bed.

A while back, I remember hearing that these bottles, which are made with Lexan, can leach unwanted chemicals into the water. I didn't heed the warning, though, until a friend -- who happens to be a scientific researcher -- mentioned that she was scared of them.

This didn't sound good.

A quick look around the web revealed that the bottles are made with Lexan, a trademarked name for polycarbonate, and that they're made with #7 plastic, apparently not a good thing. Thanks to a previous Lime article, I discovered that these bottles might leach bisphenol-A, into the drinking water. The chemical is linked to increased risk of birth defects, miscarriage, and cancer. (The article also noted that Nalgene also has a line of bottles in the safer HDPE plastic.)

My search also turned up a number of studies on bisphenol-A, along with several highly confusing chemical formulas. Even more confusing are the many conflicting interpretations about any risks. Some say it's dangerous, others aren't so sure. I was in over my head with the word "polycarbonate."

But the bottom line is that I'm looking for a water bottle that doesn't make me nervous each time I take a sip.

Metal bottles seem to be a popular alternative. But I want to be sure about them before I splurge. And I'm also still haunted by the rumor that aluminum is linked to Alzheimers' disease. Again, I don't know if the risk is real, but I'd rather to err on the side of caution.

Two leading contenders are food-grade stainless steel bottles, like these Kleen Kanteen bottles. I'm also totally charmed by Sigg bottles. Apparently, tests show that they don't leach aluminum into the water. It also comes in so many cool colors and patterns, that my inner fashionista is already swooning.

At around $20 each, I'm settled with the fact that I'll never have an impressive collection of Sigg bottles. But one will do just fine.



<em>Wendy_B.</em>'s picture
I hear you, sister
by Wendy_B. on June 5, 2007 - 11:40am

My trusty Nalgene companion was pink. My husband had an assortment rolling around constantly on the floorboard of his truck. The Nalgene bottle was an integral part of our lives - how could it forsake us!

 

We're both on Siggs now. Hope there are no nasty surprises in 10 years...


<em>Chris</em>'s picture
Are you telling me...
by Chris on June 5, 2007 - 2:15pm
That my favorite Star Wars lunch box that my mommie used to send me to school with was most likely poisoning me?
<em>Vicki_R</em>'s picture
chinese food
by Vicki_R on June 5, 2007 - 2:34pm
I also read that chinese food containers, you know the kind they put your soup in are not the healthiest either.  Also, don't reheat the pastic in the microwave or any plastic for that matter.  Very bad!!!
<em>Statuesqueone</em>'s picture
Hard to believe....
by Statuesqueone on June 5, 2007 - 3:57pm
....that we have to worry about our water bottles. I understand it but wish our world was a little safer. Who would have thought drinking bottles could be poisoning all of us?
<em>Vicki_R</em>'s picture
or take-out
by Vicki_R on June 6, 2007 - 11:27am
Or take-out chinese!
<em>silentnight</em>'s picture
attack of the waterbottles
by silentnight on June 6, 2007 - 1:21pm

I learn something new everyday. I didn’t know that water bottles could poison me, especially the ones that I buy at the store. No need to worry attacking tomatoes. Watch out for the water bottles. Thanks for the information hope to hear more on the topic as it continues.


<em>madamerebellion</em>'s picture
I guess we have more to add to our paranoia, hehe.
by madamerebellion on June 7, 2007 - 1:04pm

So I have to pay $20 per bottle to diminish the chances of poisoning myself next time I take a sip? wow.

 

I wonder if plastic bottles from Dasani,or Deja Blue are dangerous too? I've searched the net but have not found much on it.  I usually purchase those when I'm in a rush and my waterbottle is out of sight and then reuse them as much as I can.

 

 


<em>horsesmulesanddogs</em>'s picture
WATER BOTTLES
by horsesmulesanddogs on July 5, 2007 - 10:41pm
SUNRIDER HAS SAFE WATER BOTTLES;  A 16 OZ IS 6.00. A 32 OZ IS 7.00.  THE COMPANY IS OUT OF TORRANCE, CA.

User login


Join Lime Now, it's free

Meet New People

joolee (View Profile)

Interests: Food, Juicing, Eco-Urban Lifestyle, People, Music
Inspiration:

More new members | Create your profile