PrintEmail
Comment
Blind Faith: Herbal Remedies
Posted by Su Avasthi on May 31, 2007 - 4:48pm.

One of my former coworkers used to keep a bottle of echniacea in a desk drawer. The second anyone in the vicinity sneezed, he'd pop a capsule in his mouth, and then generously offer one to any takers.

He swore by the stuff, much the same way that a friend's sister swears that Hoodia helps her stay skinny and my retired neighbor tells me that ginkgo biloba helps his wife remember to turn off the oven. (Curiously, he mentioned this while standing next to the purple coneflowers -- aka echniacea -- growing in my front yard.)

Anyway, I thought about these folks -- and their folk wisdom -- while reading an article on Time.com about America's growing faith in herbal mediciations. As their popularity surges, the medical community grows increasingly concerned about remedies because we know so little about their potential benefits or hazards.

According to a new study conducted at the University of Iowa and published in the June issue of Mayo Clinic Proceedings, more Americans than ever now take herbal supplements, jumping up an astonishing 83 percent in the past decade.

The concerns revolve around the fact that roughly 20 percent of the population are counting on an herbal remedy to treat a specific ailment. More often than not, they aren't effective.

More problematic, of course, is the chance that herbal remedies could cause harm or lasting damage. Negative side effects cited in the study range from nausea to liver and kidney damage. Supplements have been tainted with unwanted chemicals or metals. Consumers risk of unpredictable interactions with prescription or over the counter drugs. And then there's the issue about how to effectively regulate this $22 billion industry

Recently, there have been efforts to provide us with facts and information about herbal remedies, such as Consumer Reports' Natural Medicines Comprehensive Database, But the question remains: Is the available data based on reliable clinical trials?

For whatever reason, I haven't personally experimented with a lot of the supplements out there. But I do keep a stash of Airborne around, in case I feel a cold coming on.

I don't know what's in the stuff or if it works. All I know is that a sales clerk at a natural foods store raved about it, and told me: If I take all of it, as directed, I'll be able to fend off the unwanted bug.

So does it actually have curative powers? Or is it just snake oil? I have no idea. But as long as it's safe, I'm happy with a placebo. Sometimes it's comforting to have a little faith in the healing powers of a pill.



<em>Vicki_R</em>'s picture
skeptical
by Vicki_R on June 1, 2007 - 11:24am
My husband says the Airborne I bought did not help him out.  I have never tried it, but Oprah swears by it, so I did by it for  him.  He travels a lot and is constantly on planes with germs.
<em>Statuesqueone</em>'s picture
Years of use
by Statuesqueone on June 6, 2007 - 4:35pm
Herbal remedies have been around for centuries, much longer than modern medicine. And who's to say modern medicine is any safer. We all remember Thalidomide  and Vioxx don't we? With extensive use around the world I feel fairly safe taking herbal supplements. Although I don't use supplements as often as I drink herb teas. I believe the teas work, it seems that my allergies are much worse when I don't drink herb teas.

I agree that more regulation is the key to safety and effective treatments. I've read that the government is becoming more and more corcerned about this unregulated industry. Hopefully they will do something sooner than later so we all can feel safer using effective herbal treatments.
<em>Vicki_R</em>'s picture
be careful
by Vicki_R on June 1, 2007 - 4:55pm
It's also important to know that certain herbs interact with certain medications badly.  Many people think that because they are herbs, they cannot do any damage.  If you are taking medication, be sure to contact your doctor or ask someone who knows herbs.
Must talk to NDs or herbalists about herbs
by skupe on June 2, 2007 - 7:22am

Most of the mass-marketed medical doctors won't know a thing about herbs.  Don't bother asking your MD.  Ask a Naturopath or an herbalist.

 

Suz


<em>Vicki_R</em>'s picture
how?
by Vicki_R on June 3, 2007 - 11:50am
How does one find an herbalist.  Are they in the yellow pages?
<em>Ecobabe</em>'s picture
Word of mouth
by Ecobabe on June 12, 2007 - 10:47pm
Hey Vicki I didn't find my Tibetan healer in the Yellow Pages I learned of him from a friend. But I bet you could find an herbalist in the Yellow pages or on Google....

Be prepared to eat some nasty tasting herbs. At least that's what my Tibetan Healer gave me, yucky tasting herbs! None of this yummy tea from your local health food market (that might be a good place to find an herbalist, ask at your local health food store).  Good luck.
<em>princetoner</em>'s picture
HOODIA
by princetoner on August 31, 2007 - 2:33pm
I'd really like to post the fact that when it comes to hoodia the buyer must watch for one thing above all others, and that is purity. As far as I know (and I've tried almost all of them), the Hoodoba brand sold at http://www.hoodia-dietpills.com is the only brand sold in the US that has no fillers or additives whatsoever. This is key in that unless it has enough of the raw hoodia powder in the capsules, the level of appetite suppression will not be strong enough to make a difference. From what I understand the other brands dilute the products with additives, and fillers, and other ingredients as much as 70-80 percent to cut corners and to cut cost. When I look under the Other Ingredients section of the label, from those that I purchased (8 different brands), the Hoodoba label is the only one that says "None". No wonder it is also the one that truly suppresses the appetite as discussed in the studies.    
<em>flixter</em>'s picture
Self-Regulation
by flixter on October 8, 2007 - 5:50pm

Its only recently that I started to take full notice of the healing power of herbs. Learning about its therapeutic benefits, I could only say that its negative side effects could not measure up to its healing potential. 

With herbal remedies not regulated by the FDA, I could only recommend self-regulation over the use of herbs.  And how is that possible? (1) consult an herbalist prior to intake; (2) when on drug medication or pregnant, get your physicians nod prior to intake; and (3) take only herbal remedies formulated by expert herbalists that are likewise prepared under strict pharmaceutical standards. There are about a number of proven safe and effective herbal remedies from this site: www.myherbalremedystore.com/


User login


Join Lime Now, it's free

Meet New People

milkyway (View Profile)

Interests: Practicing DJing, Feng Shui, Spirituality, Candle and Soap making, Yoga, Camping, Bicycling, Movies, Music
Inspiration: Music. Nature.

More new members | Create your profile