PrintEmail
Comment
The Biggest Bestest (Most Pollutionest) SUV
Posted by Belinda Miller on May 16, 2007 - 6:34am.

Georgia wants a truck. Not just a little truck—one of those huge, honkin’ SUV/truck mash-ups that looks like an armored car. You know, the truck that has to take up two parking spaces and can’t drive abreast of a Cooper Mini on a two-lane street?

This came to my attention in the parking lot of the Oregon Zoo, as I cursed SUV after mini-van parked in the Compact Only spaces. One was a particularly loathsome monster of a truck, shiny cobalt, a whopping 13 miles per gallon fuel economy, clearly never used for towing the 9,000 lbs it’s beefily capable of. As I was pondering who might drive that thing, and what they might be overcompensating for, Georgia, with her extra sensory perception that often gives me the willies, said, “Mommy, I like that verrry big blue truck! I would like to have a truck like that!”

Now here’s what went through my head: No, no, no, where did I go wrong? Are you crazy, there’s nothing beautiful about that, and it’s hardly even functional! Can you say “suburban assault vehicle?” No kid of mine is going to drive a trophy truck! Then I got mad at the toy makers who work with the car companies to create mega-super ride-on toy sport utility vehicle/trucks that build brand identity and fuel desire.

Once again, I realized I’m up against another major marketing department that goes against my core beliefs, and panic set in.

Then I stopped, and switched my brain from eco-nut to pre-school mind, and really looked at the truck. What did she see there that I couldn’t see, blinded as I am by my green-colored glasses?

“Wow, that is a pretty color of blue,” I allowed.

“It’s sparkling!” Georgia enthused. And it was true, it was clean as Chitty Chitty Bang Bang, no small feat here in the moss and pine-pollen covered Northwest. Which just set my eco-nut mind off again: I bet they don’t go to the Washman, where they recycle the wash water. I bet they wash it in their driveway and let the tainted water go straight into the over taxed waste system. They probably let the hose run. Grrrr. But I didn’t really want to demonize these unknown people, and I didn’t want to make Georgia feel bad about liking this atrocious truck. I reset my mind again.

It’s not that hard to understand, when I think about it. It makes sense that she’s attracted to that biggest, shiniest truck. She’s all about wanting to be –est right now. She wants to be the oldest, the smartest, the strongest. It’s heartbreaking when, as I try to wrangle her into her car seat, she rages “I AM STRONGER THAN YOU!” I respectfully explain that she will certainly be stronger than me someday, but, clicking her into the five-point safety system, I am currently stronger. Again and again this hurts her to the core. So she desires something that compensates for how tiny and powerless she feels. Isn’t that what those huge vehicles are really about? Giving the driver a sense of strength, power, and security that they don’t naturally possess? I get it—as a fairly small person I have thrilled at the power I felt when driving a rental truck. Yes, I do get it.

So I said, “It does sparkle. But it’s so big, it must create a lot of pollution.” Georgia didn’t bite as I had hoped, so I didn’t push it. Instead I joked, “Look how tall it is, how do you think the people get into it? Do you think they are giants?” She laughed and said, “Mommy, giants aren’t real! Maybe they are bears?” And the subject was changed. Maybe I planted a seed of doubt, a question about why someone would need such a truck, but I didn’t want to make her feel ashamed for her gut-level desire. Or maybe I should have got all in a snit and nipped it in the bud? Well, she’s sure to bring it up again, and now I have time to think about how to bring up pollution, alternative transportation, and why we drive an often dusty, somewhat mossy compact.



<em>dancingqueen</em>'s picture
not to demanding
by dancingqueen on May 16, 2007 - 8:50am
We are looking into getting a new car. I want a hybrid, my husband wants something comfortable (he's 6"5) and my boys want a tv, dvd player and a third seat in the car. Not too demanding!!!!
<em>madamerebellion</em>'s picture
You should.
by madamerebellion on May 16, 2007 - 2:13pm

I have a honda civic hybrid and I love the mileage! :) I also thinks it's awfully cool that it turns off everytime I hit the break at a stop light, then just magically turns on again when you release it.

 

And there are Hybrid SUVs so maybe you can compromise. :) 


<em>omshanti</em>'s picture
Good Luck
by omshanti on May 16, 2007 - 11:34am

The trouble is... those of us with larger families can't fit into a Prius or even an Escape. You could always buy a diesel and make a "frybrid." It's a bit of work, but maybe you could enlist your boys to help...


<em>phiggs</em>'s picture
escape the escape
by phiggs on May 17, 2007 - 9:36am

The Escape and the Toyota Highlander hybrid s are kind of a joke -- even with the hybrid engine, the overall MPG is about what you'd get out of a standard sedan. And the passenger space isn't any bigger, either.

I like the frybrid idea. I've seen a number of 80s-era Toyota Land Cruisers converted to diesel -- 35MPG, and you can run biodiesel (no petroleum involved). And diesel engines run for hundreds of thousands of miles longer than conventional engines.

From what I can tell, the conversion costs around $4000 if you do it yourself, $6000 to $8000 if someone does it for you. There's an old FJ60 for sale on my block for $4000. That's $12,000 total, about half the price of an Escape. If I were in the market for a new car, that'd be my choice. Two three-passenger bench seats, two seats up front: surely you can fit an entire family in one of those monsters. Size, power and fuel efficiency.


<em>good4you</em>'s picture
cheaper!
by good4you on May 18, 2007 - 9:15pm
I actually have done some ivestigating of my own on the subject of bio conversions, and I found this great company called arbonne and they sell converters for about 1,000 to 2,000 and than its about 400 for the filter if you want to do your own biofuel from restruants (ie- free gas!) just thought Id give you the heads up :)
<em>Magistra40</em>'s picture
Decisions, decisions...
by Magistra40 on May 16, 2007 - 1:18pm

As a family of four, we managed to live our lives and get around in a Hyndai Excel for 10 years.  Having four doors is what matters; having an entertainment centre, forty-two cup holders and seating for twenty in your "rolling living room" isn't as important as some people would think.

 Ford now makes a hybrid SUV and it isn't a monster truck.  For those eco-minded folks who need the space, it might be worth investigating.


<em>madamerebellion</em>'s picture
all in due time.
by madamerebellion on May 16, 2007 - 2:52pm

I've never really liked big cars, they make me feel uncomfortable.

I always feel I get too close to objects and it makes me feel awfully nervous. 

 

Oh and the fact that they are horrible for the environment and my checkbook (with these high gas prices and all) does discourage me to get one.

 

I'm sure that your daughter will notice this once she is a bit older and she'll truly understand, you're providing her a great upbringing.  :) 


<em>uziel_</em>'s picture
we're with ya.
by uziel_ on May 16, 2007 - 5:15pm

Let's not get too paranoid mom! Well, I often over think things too, we're all guilty of this as well it's common. 

Anyway I prefer to ride my bike especially when there is great weather, and a cloudy sky (without the rain, or sometimes even with rain!).

 

But let's face it, riding your bike everywhere is hard and impractical.

 

For the most part though, I don't like big cars because they're bad investments.  


<em>enigma_v</em>'s picture
Mother knows best.
by enigma_v on May 16, 2007 - 5:36pm

I was raised to like Monster trucks and big trucks with the teachings my dad would give me. But mother knows best and she always tried to make me understand that sometimes you have to look deeper into things and people even, before you go ahead and make a move. So as cool and macho as I would look in a big truck I know it's not even remotely convenient in the end so why bother.

 

I still enjoy looking at Monster Truck battles though.  


<em>Vicki_R</em>'s picture
ins and outs of a car
by Vicki_R on May 16, 2007 - 5:53pm
I think it is a kid thing.  They just like things that are big and beautiful to look at.  My boys miss being in my SUV when we have to borrow another car.  They like being high off the ground and honestly so do I. Teaching them about the ins * outs of what a car does to the environment is a tricky one. 
<em>BelindaMom</em>'s picture
So needy
by BelindaMom on May 16, 2007 - 10:46pm
The car issue for me is really about “need.” Some people really need a truck, minivans are essential to many families, and I’m sure some people even really need an SUV, and I am especially fond of ogling shiny 1965 Fords with whitewall tires. But I doubt that anyone needs THIS particular kind of massive, luxury sport utility truck: the company is not just selling a car, but a lifestyle that is excessive at best (and maybe even a bit paranoid). We spend our lifetime being told we need a lot of things we can easily live without, and that’s what I am fascinated (and maybe even a bit paranoid) to explore!
<em>Vicki_R</em>'s picture
suv driver
by Vicki_R on May 18, 2007 - 10:40am
You are right in that there is a difference between "need" and "want" and the lines sometimes cross.  I drive and SUV, with two boys who play sports and a husband who is 6'5 it really helps.  It's important to remember that we shouldn't judge someone based on their car decisions.  We all make choices where we need to make our carbon footprint. 

User login


Join Lime Now, it's free

Meet New People

AutumnElayne (View Profile)

Interests: Indie Crafting, Art, Astronomy, Physics, History, Eco-Friendly, Computer Graphics, Sewing, Knitting, Drawing, Macrame, Painting, Spinning,Book Binding, Screenprinting, Electronics Tinkering, Web Design, Books about my interests, Coffee, Travel, Black Tea, Cooking, Corduroy, Wool Felt, Ribbons, Vintage Patches, Collecting Sanrio paraphernalia, Boondoggle, Zines
Inspiration: Carl Sagan, Jim Henson, and Tori Amos.

More new members | Create your profile